Hire a pastor: a step-by-step guide for church search committees

The farewell reception is over, the moving truck has pulled away, and a handful of elders are sitting in the fellowship hall with a legal pad and no plan. Somebody has to preach on Sunday and answer the congregation's questions. And somebody has to work out how a church that hasn't run a search in years finds the person who will lead it next.

To hire a pastor, appoint a search committee of seven to eleven people, write a church profile and job description with a pay range, post the role through your denomination and Christian job boards, then screen sermons, interview, check references and backgrounds, and bring a finalist to the congregation. Plan on six to twelve months.

Key takeaways

Search stage	What your church decides
Committee	Who serves (seven to eleven people, an odd number) and who the committee answers to
Church profile	Who you are today: attendance trend, budget, theology, community, and recent history
Job description	The title, your top three priorities, required credentials, and a published salary range
Posting	Denominational channels, seminaries, Christian job boards, and personal networks, all at once
Vetting	Recent sermons, at least two interviews, references beyond the list, and background checks
Onboarding	A written first-year plan, reviews at six and twelve months, and a formal end to the committee

Last updated October 2026

How do you set up a pastor search committee?

A pastor search committee is the small group that works on behalf of the whole church. It builds the church profile, reads applications, interviews candidates, and brings one name forward.

How the committee forms depends on your church government. In congregational churches, including many Baptist and nondenominational congregations, members usually elect or approve the committee. In elder-led churches, the elders may serve as the committee or appoint one. In appointive denominations such as the United Methodist Church, a bishop assigns pastors, so start with your district or regional office before you do anything else.

William Vanderbloemen, whose firm runs pastor searches, recommends seven to eleven members, always an odd number so a vote can't deadlock. He also warns against seating the person who joins every committee and opposes everything.

Choose members for judgment first and representation second. Thom Rainer of Church Answers has written that committees built to represent every group in the church are often the slowest ones. A strong committee usually includes one or two elders or deacons, members from different generations, someone who hires people at work (a school principal, a nurse manager, an HR director, or a small-business owner), and one detail-minded person to run logistics.

Keep staff who will report to the new pastor off the voting roster and interview them for input instead, so nobody is choosing their own boss.

Before the first meeting, put a short charter in writing:

who the committee reports to, and who gives final approval
the vote needed to recommend a candidate (unanimous, or a set supermajority), decided before any names are on the table
a confidentiality covenant, because a leaked name can put a candidate's current position at risk
a budget for travel, background checks, and any search firm fees
how often the committee will update the congregation

Line up preaching coverage at the same time. An interim pastor or a rotation of pulpit supply preachers takes pressure off the committee, and a committee under pressure tends to settle.

What should the church profile and pastor job description say?

Write three documents before anyone posts the job: a church profile, a job description, and a compensation sheet. Candidates read the first two to decide whether to apply, and the third keeps the committee from improvising pay during the final interview.

A useful church profile covers:

average weekly attendance for the last five years, so candidates see the trend line
the annual budget and giving trend, plus any debt
staff size and which roles the pastor will supervise
your denomination or network and the doctrinal standards a pastor must affirm
the community around the church: age, growth, and what people do for work
recent history, including conflict, a split, or a predecessor who served for decades

Strong candidates will ask about recent conflict anyway. Hearing it from the committee first builds trust, and it filters out pastors who aren't suited to a hard season.

The job description should name the title precisely. A solo pastor at a small rural church and a senior pastor leading a staff of twenty do different jobs, and the posting should make that obvious. Spell out the reporting line (elder board, deacons, church council), the preaching load in Sundays per year, the pastoral care expectations, the people the pastor will supervise, required credentials such as ordination or a Master of Divinity, the salary range and benefits, the location, and the start window.

Rank three priorities and say them plainly. A description that asks for a gifted preacher, counselor, administrator, fundraiser, and youth magnet describes nobody, and the committee will end up measuring every candidate against an imaginary one. If your church is plateaued in a growing suburb, outreach may come first. If it is recovering from a previous pastor's moral failure, trust and pastoral care may outrank everything else.

How much should a church pay a new pastor?

Pastor pay depends on church size, region, budget, and the scope of the role, so start from market data and adjust for your context. According to ChristianJobsList.com salary data (as of October 2026), the 92 ministry listings from the past year with complete salary ranges had a median of about $51k, with a typical range of $42k to $63k. Our salary data reflects what employers advertised in those ministry listings, so treat it as a reference point. A senior pastor leading a large staff will likely need more.

For a second benchmark, clergy earned a median of $60,810 a year as of May 2025, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics. You can compare ministry pay with other church and nonprofit roles on our Christian salary data page.

Publish the range in the posting. In our salary data, only 92 of the 330 ministry listings from the past year included a complete salary range, so a church that shows its numbers stands out. A pastor with a family can't decide whether to apply without them, and candidates who need more will self-select out before they take up an interview slot.

A pastor's compensation package usually has more parts than a typical job offer:

Base salary. The cash portion, set by the board or finance committee before posting.
Housing allowance. The IRS lets a minister exclude a housing allowance from income tax, but only if the church designates it in advance, usually by board resolution. The exclusion is capped at the lowest of the designated amount, the actual housing cost, and the home's fair rental value.
Self-employment tax offset. Ministers are treated as self-employed for Social Security and Medicare, so they pay the full self-employment tax themselves, as IRS Publication 517 explains. Some churches add an offset to cover part of that cost.
Retirement and health coverage. Many denominations run their own plans, such as GuideStone for Southern Baptist churches.
Time and growth. Vacation, study leave, conference funds, and a sabbatical policy after a set number of years.
Moving costs. A relocation budget, agreed in writing before the candidate accepts.

Where should you post a pastor job opening?

Post in several places at the same time. Rainer lists waiting on denominational publications and reading resumes one at a time among the habits that make searches drag. A broad posting plan includes:

Your denomination's or network's placement office, regional body, or association.
Career and alumni offices at seminaries in your tradition.
Christian job boards that carry pastor and ministry openings.
Your church website, newsletter, and social media accounts.
Personal networks: pastors your elders trust, leaders of nearby churches, and mission agency contacts.
A pastor search firm, if the budget allows. Ask how the fee is calculated and what happens if the placement doesn't last.

Every posting should list the salary range, location, start window, and exactly what to send: a resume, links to two or three recent sermons, answers to a short doctrinal questionnaire, and references. Set an application deadline and a review date so candidates know when they'll hear back.

If an associate pastor already on staff wants the lead role, consider that candidate openly and run the same process. Skipping steps for an insider makes it harder for the congregation to trust the result.

How do you interview and vet pastor candidates?

Vetting runs in stages when you hire a pastor, and each stage narrows the pool before the committee spends travel money or weekend time.

Listen to sermons before you read resumes closely

Ask for full recordings of recent services, not a highlight reel. Two or three sermons from different months show how a candidate handles ordinary Sundays. Save a live visit for finalists, since video covers most of the early screening.

Ask questions that show how a candidate leads

Good interview questions ask for past behavior. A few that work for most churches:

Tell us about a decision your board opposed and what you did next.
How do you prepare a sermon across a normal week?
Which part of our job description would be hardest for you?
How have you handled a staff member who wasn't doing the job?
What would you leave unchanged during your first year here?

Check references beyond the list

The candidate's chosen references will speak well of them. Call those references, then ask each one for another person who knows the candidate's ministry, such as a former board chair or staff member. Get the candidate's permission before calling anyone at their current church. Chuck Lawless notes that committees now review candidates' social media as part of vetting, so read a finalist's public posts before the weekend visit.

Check criminal history and sex offender registries for every finalist. Add a driving record if the pastor will drive church vehicles and a credit check if the role handles church money. Verify ordination and degrees directly with the issuing body. When you use a screening company, federal law requires a written disclosure and the candidate's written permission, as the EEOC and FTC guide on background checks explains. Your insurance carrier may have its own requirements, so ask.

Hold a candidating weekend and a vote

The finalist preaches, meets staff and leaders, answers questions from members, and has time to see the community with their family. Your bylaws set the vote needed to call a pastor, so read them before the weekend. After the vote, send a written call letter that lists the full compensation package, start date, moving support, and review schedule.

Churches have wide legal room here. In Hosanna-Tabor v. EEOC (2012), the Supreme Court recognized a ministerial exception that keeps courts out of a religious group's choice of its ministers. Still, have an attorney familiar with church law review your process once.

How long does it take to hire a pastor?

Rainer has argued that "in most cases, a church should be able to get a new pastor in six months or less." Writing in 2024, Lawless observed that "it takes many churches at least a year in their search for a new pastor," pointing to high resume volume, cautious vetting, and congregations researching candidates on their own.

A workable plan looks something like this:

Search phase	Planning window
Form the committee and arrange preaching coverage	Weeks 1 to 4
Church profile, job description, and pay range	Months 1 to 2
Posting and collecting applications	Months 2 to 4
Sermon review and interviews	Months 3 to 6
Candidating weekend, vote, and call letter	Months 5 to 8
Notice period and relocation	Depends on the candidate's current church and move

Treat the table as a planning guide. Denominational approvals and a finalist who withdraws can each add months.

How do you welcome and onboard a new pastor?

Onboarding starts before the first Sunday. Have housing settled, the office ready, and keys, email, and payroll set up. Send the congregation a letter introducing the pastor and their family, and schedule a meeting with the interim pastor so pastoral care cases are handed over properly.

During the first 90 days, give the new pastor a list of people to meet: elders, staff, key volunteers, longtime members, and homebound members who can't easily come to them. Many pastors use those early months to listen before proposing changes, and the board can protect that time by not handing over a list of fixes on day one.

Decide in writing who will review the pastor's work and when. A personnel committee or the elder board should hold check-ins at six and twelve months, using the three priorities from the job description as the measure.

Then formally thank and dissolve the search committee. A committee that keeps meeting after the hire can turn into a second board, and the new pastor needs one clear line of accountability. Some churches form a small transition team for the first year instead, to answer questions and pass along feedback.

The arrival of a new pastor also tends to show where support is thin. If the pastor ends up spending hours on scheduling and bookkeeping, a church administrator can free that time, and our church administration listings show how other churches describe those roles.

What mistakes stall a pastor search?

These habits stall pastor searches:

choosing a candidate as a reaction to the last pastor, either a copy or the opposite
evaluating one candidate at a time, so every withdrawal sends the committee back to the start
letting candidate names leak outside the room
posting without a salary range and losing good applicants in the final interview
going months without updating the congregation, which invites rumors
skipping the background check because a candidate is well known

Frequently asked questions

How long does it take for a church to find a new pastor?

Timelines vary widely. Thom Rainer has written that most churches should be able to call a new pastor in six months or less, while Chuck Lawless noted in 2024 that many churches search for at least a year, citing high resume volume and cautious vetting after a hard experience.

How many people should be on a pastor search committee?

William Vanderbloemen suggests seven to eleven members, in an odd number so votes can't deadlock. A very small church may need fewer. Choose members for spiritual maturity and sound judgment, include at least one person with hiring experience, and keep staff who will report to the new pastor off the voting roster.

Who hires the pastor of a church?

Church government decides who hires the pastor. Congregational churches usually vote on a candidate recommended by a search committee. Elder-led churches often let the elders decide, sometimes with a congregational affirmation. In appointive denominations such as the United Methodist Church, a bishop assigns the pastor after consulting with the local church.

What qualifications should a church look for in a pastor?

Start with the character qualifications in 1 Timothy 3 and Titus 1, then add what your denomination requires, such as ordination or a seminary degree. Beyond those, match experience to your top priorities, whether that is preaching, pastoral care, staff leadership, or revitalizing a declining church. Verify credentials for every finalist.

Should a church use a pastor search firm?

A search firm makes sense when your committee lacks hiring experience, your network is thin, or the role is a senior pastor position over a large staff. Firms charge fees, so ask how the fee is calculated and whether it includes a replacement guarantee. Smaller churches often rely on denominational channels and job boards instead.

Write the church profile before anyone reads a resume

Churches that hire a pastor well tend to know who they are before they decide who they need. Before your committee's first meeting, pull five years of attendance and giving figures and write one page on what the church needs from its next pastor over the next three years. Every later step, from the job description to the final vote, gets easier with that page on the table.

Discover Christian job opportunities across every industry at ChristianJobsList.com. You can find work in education, healthcare, counseling, finance, marketing, and more at Christian schools, hospitals, nonprofits, and companies that share your faith and values.